MPs do not – and should not – always follow judicial orders | Letters

Thu, 26 Dec 2024, 17:26
Full Content
Full article content available

Stephen Sedley, writing of parliament’s freedom of speech and action, says it has “for centuries reciprocated by respecting court decisions and orders” (

Letters, 19 December

). This is to forget, for example, the 2011 naming, in defiance of court orders, of

Ryan Giggs

and

Fred Goodwin

, the origins of which lay in the Trafigura controversy of 2009, when solicitors who had claimed MPs were covered by a gagging injunction

withdrew their claim

after an MP referred to the injunction in a written question.

The reality is that although the Commons has a rule restricting references in the house to current court cases (the “sub judice” rule), it reserves the right to defy judges who threaten to ignore their duty to respect parliamentary free speech. The same also applies to judicial attempts to undermine parliament’s ability to protect itself from people who illegitimately interfere with its work.

Parliament should exercise its rights with moderation and restraint, but judges should also show moderation and restraint when their rulings might restrict democratic decision-making. Parliamentarians might be finding moderation and restraint difficult to achieve in the current overwrought state of politics, but that is no excuse for judges to abandon those qualities, which lie at the heart of any reasonable conception of the rule of law.

David Howarth


Professor of law and public policy,

University of Cambridge

; MP for Cambridge 2005-10

• Do you have a photograph you’d like to share with Guardian readers? If so, please

click here

to upload it. A selection will be published in our

Readers’ best photographs galleries

and in the print edition on Saturdays.

AI Model Selection

Avg. Response: 10.0s

Llama3.2:1b

Meta
Default
Size: 1B
Success Rate: 100.0%

Llama-3.2-1B-Instruct-GGUF

Meta
Size: 1B
Success Rate: 100.0%
All models run locally on our servers. Response times may vary based on server load.